Key West has a wide variety of dining options, and at times it may be difficult to choose. But eating is one of the most enjoyable Key West activities – that is, if you know the best spots! 

Not to mention, hopping from museum to museum or activity to activity requires sustenance. Why not treat yourself to some of Key West’s best while you’re at it?

With its proximity to the Atlantic and the Gulf, locally caught, deliciously fresh seafood is the star of the show here.  Key West is known for its pink shrimp, crab, spiny lobsters, and other water-bound creatures. Although seafood is king here, there’s lots more to choose from. Keep reading to discover our favorite dining spots (not in any particular order!)

Latitudes

If you’re looking for dinner and activity, then Latitudes may be the best place in Key West. Located on a private island, restaurant-goers will need to take a boat ride to dine here.

Latitudes is the perfect place for a date night, as its secluded and romantic atmosphere make it a must for those looking to have an evening just to themselves.

You can check out the menu here and you’ll also need to make a reservation ahead of time. Visit their Instagram for mouthwatering pics & breathtaking views.

Date and Thyme

If you’re someone looking for vegetarian food, it might be hard to find solid options in a city filled with seafood. Thankfully, that’s why Date and Thyme is here. 

Date and Thyme has everything you can think of, from snacks to full meals. You should try their Acai bowls, wraps, or even their local island burrito. It’s perfect for a quick stop during the day before you head back out to your daily activities. 

Check out their menu and location, plus gorgeous pics of their platters on their Instagram.

Thirsty Mermaid

We’ve been dodging seafood long enough, it’s time to get your fill of oysters, fish, shrimp, and more at this locally owned restaurant. 

The Thirsty Mermaid prides itself on being supplied by local ingredients so you know that your meal is coming from the ocean waters you’ve been lounging by all day.

If you’re a craft beer fan, you’ll feel right at home at the Thirsty Mermaid. The bar is stocked with plenty of local beers but also some from around the country. 

They also have a full wine selection for any wannabe sommeliers out there.

Take a look at their Instagram and try not to get too hungry. 

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

When it comes to unique restaurants in Key West, the Flaming Buoy Filet Co. has to be near the top of the list. The restaurant is stuffed with Star Wars memorabilia and has some head-turning menu items like the Marinated & Grilled Key West Pink Shrimp with spice lime chutney, or the Lobster Thermidor with bacon-wrapped scallops. “Local additions, like seafood, tropical fruits, and Cuban flavors reinterpret the nostalgia, and the result grabbed the attention of The New York Times.” (The Flaming Buoy FB page.)

They are also a wine-lovers heaven and have wine bottles lining the wall, meaning you’ll be able to find your perfect wine to go with your lobster mac and cheese or fresh catch and banana salsa plate. 

Living up to their name, they also have other selections besides seafood if you’re wanting to dig into some ribs or even a Coney Island-style hot dog.

Last but not least, the restaurant vibe is one-of-a-kind. They pride themselves on making a statement on the hushed stage of a residential neighborhood. They consider themselves one part retro supper club, one part sassy corner bistro, and part highly personal whim.

Check out their menu and Facebook page to be shocked & awed ;)

Glazed

For all the sweet-tooths out there, Glazed is a must. We’ll give you one guess as to what their main draw is. 

That’s right, donuts. Delicious, jelly-filled, donuts. They also roast their own coffee! It’s the best cuppa joe in town.

Glazed does shut down early at 3 PM every day, so make sure you’re heading there with plenty of time to spare. Of course, the earlier in the day the more fresh and tasty these sugary treats are bound to be.

Take a look at their menu here & look at the yummy posts people have tagged on Instagram here >

Hogfish Bar & Grill

Another island adventure, Hogfish Bar & Grill is located on Stock Island and is the ultimate destination for any seafood lovers. The setting is perfect, as the restaurant is situated on a covered dock, perfect for a late afternoon meal or to watch the sunset. 

The menu is absolutely loaded with delicious seafood items, from shrimp to local fish, including Killer Tuna Nachos & Conch Ceviche… Yum.  If you’ve come to Key West for seafood and little else, then this place should be at the top of your list.

Check out their menu here.

Café Marquesa

This swanky spot is located at the Marquesa Hotel. The chef here hails from Charleston’s famous Peninsual Grill, meaning that the food served at the Café boasts fresh Key West flavors with a South Carolinian twist. Try the crispy local yellowtail snapper on parmesan grits and seared sea scallops with a bit of spicy Andouille sausage. If you’re tired of seafood, try the seared duck breast and high-flavor ribeye. Absolutely stunning!

Head to their Instagram for more inspiring dishes. Make sure to reserve before heading over!

Ready to Eat?

It’s impossible not to be hungry after reading through this expansive list of fantastic dining options. Are there any places that you’ve been to that you feel like we left off the list? Let us know!

If you’re a first-time visitor to Key West or looking to make the trip, be sure and reach out to us! We can offer everything from activity recommendations to must-see places. We can’t wait to see you!